Which is the stronger acid: PH3 or H2S?

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

\(H_{2}S\)

Reasoning

Electronegativity: $S > P$. Bond polarity: $H-S > H-P$. Partial charge on $H$: $\delta+(H-S) > \delta+(H-P)$. Therefore, $H_{2}S$ is more acidic.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Identify the electronegativity of the central atoms: Sulfur ($S$) is more electronegative than Phosphorus ($P$).
  2. Relate electronegativity to bond polarity: Because $S$ is more electronegative, the $H-S$ bond is more polar than the $H-P$ bond.
  3. Determine the effect on charge: A more polar bond results in a greater partial positive charge ($\delta+$) on the hydrogen atom.
  4. Conclude acid strength: Since a higher partial positive charge makes the hydrogen more acidic, $H_{2}S$ is the stronger acid.