Why was James the 2nd having a son "the last straw" for English Protestants?

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

They realized that England could be subject to a Catholic dynasty.

Reasoning

James II (Catholic) + Son (Catholic heir) = Catholic dynasty threat to Protestant England.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Understand the context: James II was a Catholic king ruling a predominantly Protestant England.
  2. Analyze the threat: Before the birth of his son, the heir to the throne was his Protestant daughter, Mary. The birth of a son meant that the son would take precedence in the line of succession.
  3. Identify the 'last straw': Because the son would be raised Catholic, his birth signaled the potential for a permanent Catholic dynasty, which was the primary fear of the English Protestant establishment.