Which is the best replacement for the underlined sentence: The house had been unusu...

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

The house was unusually dark for early evening.

Why

Narrative tense: past. 'The house was unusually dark for early evening' matches the simple past tense used throughout the paragraph.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Identify the tense of the surrounding narrative: The story is written in the past tense (e.g., 'pulled', 'peered', 'thought').
  2. Evaluate the options: The original sentence uses the past perfect ('had been'), which implies the state of darkness happened before another past action. However, the simple past ('was') is the most direct and natural way to describe the state of the house at that moment in the narrative.
  3. Select the best fit: 'The house was unusually dark for early evening' maintains the consistent past tense of the paragraph and is the most concise and idiomatic choice.