Is Eating Eggs Significantly Associated with Mortality? (a) The proportion dying of...

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

1. True 2. False

Reasoning

Significant difference + lower observed proportion = True for (a). Not significant difference = False for (b) as a 'must be true' claim.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Analyze the study results: The text states that the proportion of deaths was lower in the group eating eggs weekly compared to those eating them infrequently. This difference was statistically significant for cardiovascular deaths.
  2. Evaluate statement (a): Since the difference for cardiovascular deaths was statistically significant and the overall trend was lower for the weekly group, it is true that the proportion dying of cardiovascular disease was lower in the weekly group.
  3. Evaluate statement (b): The text explicitly states that the difference for deaths due to cancer was not statistically significant. Therefore, we cannot conclude that the proportion was lower, nor can we definitively say it was not lower; however, in the context of statistical significance testing, 'not significant' means we fail to reject the null hypothesis of no difference. Thus, the claim that it was 'not lower' (implying a specific direction or lack of difference) is not supported as a 'must be true' statement in the same way as the significant finding.