How does the author support the main idea in this paragraph?

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

with an example that shows a specific brutal living condition

Step-by-step solution

  1. Analyze the main idea: The paragraph argues that many of the Grimm brothers' early stories were not about fairies or happy endings, but rather about the 'brutal living conditions' of the nineteenth century.
  1. Evaluate the supporting evidence: To support the claim that these stories reflect brutal living conditions, the author provides a specific example from the story 'The Children of Famine.'
  1. Examine the example: The author quotes the beginning of the story, where a mother is so desperate due to extreme poverty and hunger that she considers killing her children to eat. This text serves as a concrete, specific example of the 'brutal living condition' (starvation/extreme poverty) mentioned in the main idea.

4. Compare with options:
- The first option is the main idea itself, not the supporting evidence.
- The second option lists titles, which introduces the topic but does not illustrate the 'brutal living condition' as effectively as the narrative excerpt.
- The third option is incorrect because the text suggests the stories are not fit for children.
- The fourth option correctly identifies that the author uses a specific narrative excerpt to demonstrate a 'brutal living condition.'