The urine of five different people was tested and the results are shown in a table....

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

Shona

Step-by-step solution

  1. Analyze the medical conditions and hydration levels: To solve this, we must determine how each person's health or activity affects their urine composition. Uncontrolled diabetes typically leads to high blood sugar levels, causing sugar to be excreted in the urine. Kidney disease can damage the filtration system, allowing protein to leak into the urine. Hydration levels affect the concentration and color: high water intake results in very dilute, almost clear urine, while dehydration (from exercise in heat) results in dark, concentrated urine.

2. Match the specific indicators to the samples: We can now link each person to a sample based on the table data:
- Carl has uncontrolled diabetes, so his urine should contain sugar. This matches Sample 4.
- Vicci has kidney disease, so her urine should contain protein. This matches Sample 1.
- Andy ran a marathon in hot weather and would be dehydrated, leading to dark urine. This matches Sample 2.
- Dinesh drank a large volume of water ($1.5\text{ L}$), which would make his urine very dilute. This matches Sample 5 (Almost clear).

  1. Identify Sample 3: After matching the others, we are left with Shona and Sample 3. Shona is healthy and drank a normal amount of water ($700\text{ ml}$), which would result in a standard pale or medium-colored urine with no sugar or protein. This perfectly matches the data for Sample 3.