Which quotations from The Crab That Played with the Sea convey a comic tone?

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

1. "He took the Elephant—All-the-Elephant-there-was—and said, 'Play at being an Elephant.'" 2. "All-the-Cow-there-was . . . licked her tongue round a whole forest at a time."

Step-by-step solution

  1. Analyze the literary style: Rudyard Kipling's 'Just So Stories', including 'The Crab That Played with the Sea', are known for their whimsical, hyperbolic, and playful language, which creates a comic tone.

2. Evaluate the options:
- 'O my Best Beloved': This is a recurring, affectionate address used by the narrator, but it is more of a stylistic signature than a specific source of comic imagery.
- 'He took the Elephant—All-the-Elephant-there-was—and said, 'Play at being an Elephant.'': This uses humorous, exaggerated phrasing ('All-the-Elephant-there-was') and a silly premise, which contributes to the comic tone.
- 'All-the-Cow-there-was . . . licked her tongue round a whole forest at a time.': This uses extreme hyperbole and absurd imagery, which is a hallmark of the comic tone in these stories.
- 'The great Sea . . . overflowed all the dark forests for miles and miles, and flooded the Man's house.': This describes a dramatic, destructive event, which is more serious in nature.
- 'By and by the Eldest Magician met the Man on the banks of the Perak river.': This is a straightforward, narrative statement without specific comic elements.

  1. Conclusion: The two options that best convey a comic tone through hyperbole and whimsical phrasing are the ones involving the Elephant and the Cow.