What had they planned to happen to Ani?

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

She would become Una Wexford, once the real Una had been buried at sea

Reasoning

The plot involves replacing the original Una with Ani to fulfill the requirements of the lighthouse keeper's family.

Step-by-step solution

In the story 'The Girl Who Fell Beneath the Sea' (or similar narratives involving this plot point), the plan for Ani is to take the identity of Una Wexford after the real Una is disposed of at sea.