Which one of the following changes is incorrect?
Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.
Answer
NaBr added to a solution of HBr will raise the pH.
Reasoning
- $NaC_{2}H_{3}O_{2} + HC_{2}H_{3}O_{2} \rightarrow$ Buffer (pH rises)
- $KNO_{3} + HCl \rightarrow$ No reaction (pH constant)
- $HNO_{3} + Ca(C_{2}H_{3}O_{2})_{2} \rightarrow$ $HC_{2}H_{3}O_{2}$ (pH lowers)
- $CaCl_{2} + HCl \rightarrow$ No reaction (pH constant)
- $NaBr + HBr \rightarrow$ No reaction (pH constant, not raised)
Step-by-step solution
- Analyze each option based on acid-base principles:
- $NaC_{2}H_{3}O_{2}$ is the conjugate base of $HC_{2}H_{3}O_{2}$. Adding it creates a buffer, shifting equilibrium to consume $H^{+}$ and raising pH. This is correct.
- $KNO_{3}$ is a neutral salt (from strong acid $HNO_{3}$ and strong base $KOH$). Adding it to $HCl$ does not change the pH. This is correct.
- $HNO_{3}$ is a strong acid. Adding it to $Ca(C_{2}H_{3}O_{2})_{2}$ (a salt of a weak acid) will protonate the acetate ions, but the overall solution will become more acidic, lowering the pH. This is correct.
- $CaCl_{2}$ is a neutral salt. Adding it to $HCl$ does not change the pH. This is correct.
- $NaBr$ is a neutral salt. Adding it to $HBr$ (a strong acid) does not change the pH because $Br^{-}$ is not a base in water. The statement that it raises the pH is incorrect.