(b) State which of the possible results provide no evidence for the claim.

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

Samples B and D

Reasoning

Controlled experiment requires changing one variable. If two samples have identical variables, they provide no evidence for the claim.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Identify the claim: A scientific claim is supported by comparing samples where only one variable changes (a controlled experiment).
  2. Analyze the samples: If two samples have the same independent variable and the same dependent variable, they provide no evidence for a causal relationship.
  3. Select the pair: Based on the experimental data, Samples B and D show identical conditions and outcomes, meaning they do not isolate a variable to test the claim.