Which of these relations are functions? Select all that apply.

Check the final answer first, then review the worked steps.

Answer

Top-right, bottom-left, and bottom-right graphs

Work

Vertical Line Test:
- Top-left: Fails (two points at same $x$)
- Top-right: Passes (open/closed circles resolve overlap)
- Bottom-left: Passes (no overlapping $x$)
- Bottom-right: Passes (open/closed circles resolve overlap)

Step-by-step solution

  1. Apply the Vertical Line Test: A relation is a function if every vertical line passes through the graph at most once.
  2. Check the top-left graph: At the $x$-value where the two segments overlap vertically, there are two points. It fails the test.
  3. Check the top-right graph: At the $x$-value where the parabola and the segment overlap, there is a closed circle and an open circle, so it passes. It is a function.
  4. Check the bottom-left graph: There are three distinct horizontal segments at different $y$-levels, but they share no $x$-values. It passes the test. It is a function.
  5. Check the bottom-right graph: At the $x$-value where the two horizontal segments overlap, there is a closed circle and an open circle, so it passes. It is a function.